Key takeaways
- Compare five indoor herb garden kits for kitchen counters: three AeroGarden models, a soil-pod Click and Grow, and a 12-pod iDOO system, all as listed.
What's inside
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. This post may contain affiliate links at no extra cost to you.
- Top Pick: AeroGarden Harvest Elite 360, White
- Runner-up: AeroGarden Harvest Elite 360, White
- Also consider: AeroGarden Harvest Elite 360, White
Fresh basil for pasta, mint for tea and chives for eggs usually mean a supermarket bunch that wilts before it is used up. Indoor garden kits put a small crop on the counter instead, growing herbs under their own LED grow lights on a windowsill or worktop, with the water held in a reservoir rather than a plant pot.
The five kits here split into two camps. The three AeroGarden models and the iDOO are hydroponic systems that grow plants in water from seed pods. The Click and Grow is different: it grows in soil pods, not water, and its section below says so plainly. Pod counts run from 3 to 12. Every feature in this guide comes from the listings themselves; where a listing does not state a figure, we say so. No listing here can promise how well your herbs will grow, and neither do we.
As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.
Quick answer
For a ready-to-start hydroponic kit, the AeroGarden Harvest Elite 360 grows 6 pods under a 20W light with a timer and includes a herb seed pod kit. The iDOO grows the most pods, 12, but seeds are not included. The Click and Grow Smart Garden 3 is the small soil-pod option, with 3 pods.
AeroGarden Harvest Elite 360, White
The Harvest Elite 360 is the most fully specified AeroGarden in this guide. It grows 6 pods, and its grow light is a 20W full-spectrum LED with an automatic on/off timer, so the light runs on a schedule without you switching it daily. The listing gives a grow height of up to 12 inches, which is the headroom your plants get under the light.
A Gourmet Herb Seed Pod Kit is included, per the listing, so the box contains what you need to start a first crop of herbs. For a windowsill herb garden that begins the day it arrives, that completeness is the appeal of this model over the larger iDOO below, which holds more pods but no seeds.
This is a hydroponic garden: the pods sit in water, not soil. The White finish is this listing; other finishes of AeroGarden models are separate listings with their own ASINs.
Check the listing for current availability before ordering.
AeroGarden Harvest Elite, Stainless Steel
The Harvest Elite in stainless steel also grows 6 pods under a 20W LED grow light, per its listing. The difference a buyer can actually verify from the listing facts gathered here is the finish: stainless steel rather than white plastic, which suits kitchens where the garden will sit on open display next to steel appliances.
Beyond the pod count, light wattage and finish, the listing facts gathered for this model are limited, and further feature details are not stated in them. If a timer or a specific seed kit matters to you, confirm it on this listing’s product page rather than assuming it matches the Elite 360 above, because features must not be transferred between models.
As a hydroponic 6-pod garden with a metal finish, it sits between the plainer Harvest below and the Elite 360: same pod count as both, a finish upgrade over the basic model, and a feature list you should verify line by line before ordering.
AeroGarden Harvest, White
The Harvest is the straightforward 6-pod AeroGarden in this guide. Its listing states a 20W LED grow light, and a herb seed pod kit is included per the listing, so like the Elite 360 it can be started with what is in the box.
It is a hydroponic system, growing from pods in water. With the same pod count and light wattage as the two Elite models above, the choice between the three AeroGardens comes down to finish and to the extra features each listing states — the Elite 360 lists an automatic on/off timer and a grow height of up to 12 inches, while this Harvest listing’s gathered facts do not state a timer, so treat that detail as not stated here and check the product page if it matters to you.
For a first indoor herb garden on a kitchen windowsill, this is the simple option: six pods, a light, and a seed kit included. Gardeners who already know they want a timer schedule or a steel finish should look at the Elite models instead.
Click and Grow Smart Garden 3, Grey
The Click and Grow Smart Garden 3 is the small kit here, with 3 pods, and it works differently from everything else in this guide. It uses Smart Soil pods: this is a soil-pod system, NOT a hydroponic one, and the distinction matters. Your herbs grow in soil held in pods, watered from a self-watering reservoir, under an LED grow light. Basil pods are included, per the listing evidence.
That soil-based approach suits anyone who prefers the familiarity of soil and a compact three-pod footprint on a narrow windowsill. The trade-offs are scale — three pods against six or twelve elsewhere here — and information: the tank size and light wattage are not stated in the Amazon evidence retrieved for this listing, so those figures are not given in this guide. Check the product page if either number decides your purchase.
Buy this one for a modest start: a few pots of basil and room to add pods later, in the smallest format here. If you specifically want hydroponic growing, skip it and choose an AeroGarden or the iDOO.
iDOO Hydroponics Growing System Kit, 12 Pods
The iDOO is the capacity pick: 12 pods, double any other kit in this guide. Its listing states a 4-litre water tank, a built-in fan, an automatic timer, and a light whose height adjusts up to 11.3 inches as plants grow. The tank size is worth noting because it is the only one stated in this guide; the AeroGarden listings gathered here do not give tank figures.
One limit is stated plainly in the listing copy: seeds are NOT included. The hardware arrives ready, but your first crop needs pods or seeds bought separately, so factor that into the plan and the budget before comparing it with the AeroGardens that bundle a seed pod kit.
With twelve pods and a fan-assisted, timer-run light, this is the kit for a household that cooks with several herbs at once and has the counter space to give it. It is also the one to skip if counter space is tight or if you want to plant something the day the box arrives.
Check the listing for current availability before ordering.
How to choose
Start with the growing method, because it splits this guide in two. The AeroGarden models and the iDOO are hydroponic: pods in water, fed from a reservoir. The Click and Grow grows in Smart Soil pods instead. Neither method is promised to grow better by these listings; pick the one you prefer to maintain.
Next, count pods against your cooking. Three pods cover a herb or two for garnish. Six pods, the AeroGarden size, suit a rotation of everyday cooking herbs. Twelve pods, the iDOO, fit households that use several herbs weekly — but remember its seeds are not included, while the Harvest Elite 360 and Harvest include a herb seed pod kit and the Click and Grow includes basil pods.
Then check the light. Wattage is stated for the AeroGardens at 20W; the iDOO and Click and Grow light wattages are not stated in the evidence gathered here. Timers are listed for the Elite 360 and the iDOO. Grow height is stated for the Elite 360 at up to 12 inches and for the iDOO light at up to 11.3 inches; for the other kits it is not stated, so check the product page if tall herbs are the plan.
Finally, measure your space. Pod count is a fair proxy for footprint, and a 12-pod system needs a clear stretch of counter or windowsill. Tank size is stated only for the iDOO, at 4 litres.
Who should skip
Skip the iDOO if you want to plant on day one, because its listing states seeds are not included. Skip the Click and Grow if you specifically want hydroponics; it is a soil-pod system. Skip the 12-pod iDOO if your windowsill or counter space is limited. Skip the smaller 3-pod kit if you cook with many herbs and would outgrow it in a month. And skip the whole category if you expect guaranteed results: no listing here promises a harvest, and growth depends on the plants, the light schedule and your kitchen conditions.
FAQ
Which of these kits are hydroponic?
The three AeroGarden models and the iDOO grow in water-based hydroponic systems. The Click and Grow Smart Garden 3 is not hydroponic: it uses Smart Soil pods, as listed, with a self-watering reservoir.
Do the kits come with seeds?
The Harvest Elite 360 includes a Gourmet Herb Seed Pod Kit, the Harvest lists a herb seed pod kit included, and the Click and Grow includes basil pods. The iDOO listing states seeds are not included. For the Harvest Elite in stainless steel, seed kit inclusion is not stated in the facts gathered here.
How tall can the plants grow?
The Harvest Elite 360 lists a grow height of up to 12 inches, and the iDOO light adjusts up to 11.3 inches. Grow heights for the other kits are not stated in the listings used here.
Do the lights switch themselves on and off?
The Harvest Elite 360 lists an automatic on/off timer for its light, and the iDOO lists an automatic timer. Timer details for the other models are not stated in the facts gathered here, so check the product page if a light schedule matters to you.
Final verdict
For most kitchens, the AeroGarden Harvest Elite 360 is the complete package here: 6 pods, a 20W light on a timer, and a seed pod kit in the box. Choose the Harvest for the same 6-pod start in plainer form, the stainless Elite for the finish, the iDOO if you want 12 pods and accept that seeds are separate, and the Click and Grow for a small soil-pod garden that starts with basil.
Related guides
More from Amazon
Programs that pair well with the guide above. Offers and eligibility are set by Amazon and may change.
Free shipping on eligible items, Prime Video and more. Eligible new members can start with a free trial.
Start a Prime free trialAudiobooks and podcasts to listen to on the go. Eligible new members can start with a free trial.
Try Audible freeAd-free music streaming. Eligible new subscribers can start with a free trial.
Try Music Unlimited freeA free business account with business pricing and bulk-buying tools for work, shop or home office.
Create a business accountAs an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.





Write Your Review
No reviews yet. Be the first to share your experience!